U-Boat War Badge with Diamonds from the Estate of Kapitän zur See Wolfgang Lüth

This is a private commission made for Lüth, circa 1943. The badge is the classic production of the firm Schwerin, Berlin, 1st model. Non-ferrous metal, fire-gilt, the reverse with the maker's mark "Schwerin Berlin 68". The swastika, in the small version set with 9 simulated stones (simili), is applied separately as a plate; the rim borders are finely beaded and polished. The reverse has a bulbous pin with a round pin catch. The badge shows only minimal wear, with more than 90% of the original fire-gilding on the obverse still preserved.
Width 48.24 mm, height 38.77 mm, weight 25.49 g. A very fine piece with great presence. Very rare, one of the very few originals.

This piece is also illustrated in the catalog "Auszeichnungen des 3. Reiches" by Sascha Weber and Lothar Bichlmaier, page 47.

Accompanied by the original confirmation from the widow, Mrs. Ilse Lüth (married to Wolfgang Lüth since 1939), dated 1977, to the buyer at that time, the well-known collector and dealer Lothar Hartung (deceased), stating that this is her husband's piece; verbatim: ".. In 1943 my husband was presented by Großadmiral Dönitz with a U-Boat War Badge with Diamonds. In order to protect this badge from loss or damage while on duty, he had the above-mentioned second piece made as a duplicate by a jeweler in Lübeck. My husband wore this badge from then on, including on the day of his [death] on May 14, 1945...."




Kapitän zur See Wolfgang Lüth
Wolfgang Lüth (born October 15, 1913, in Riga; died May 14, 1945, in Flensburg) was one of the most highly decorated German naval officers, finally holding the rank of Kapitän zur See. Lüth and Albrecht Brandi were the only U-boat commanders to be awarded the Knight's Cross of the Iron Cross with Oak Leaves, Swords and Diamonds.
On April 1, 1933, he joined the Reichsmarine as an officer candidate (Crew 1933). He was promoted to Seekadett on September 23, 1933, to Fähnrich zur See on July 1, 1934, to Oberfähnrich zur See on April 1, 1936, to Leutnant zur See on October 1, 1936, and to Oberleutnant zur See on June 1, 1938.

Lüth first completed several courses and training assignments aboard surface ships and began his submarine training on February 1, 1937. During this time he was awarded the Wehrmacht Long Service Award, 4th Class, on March 31, 1937, and, together with the other crew members of U 27, the Spanish Cross in Bronze on July 6, 1939.
During the first months of the war in 1939, Lüth served as watch officer under Kapitänleutnant Heinrich Liebe aboard U 38. The boat had already left Wilhelmshaven on August 19, 1939, in order to be prepared for any eventuality.

He served on various boats as First Watch Officer and aboard U 13 as acting commander, until he became commander of U 9 (Type II B) on December 28, 1939. On six war patrols he sank eight ships totaling 17,221 GRT, including, on his penultimate patrol, the French submarine Doris. During this period he received several decorations, including the Iron Cross 2nd and 1st Class on January 25 and May 15, 1940.

On June 27, 1940, Lüth took over the Type II D boat U 138, with which he operated in the North Atlantic until October 19, 1940. On two war patrols totaling 27 days at sea he sank five ships totaling 39,971 GRT. He was mentioned in the Wehrmacht communiqué on September 23, 1940, and was awarded the Knight's Cross of the Iron Cross on October 24, 1940.

On October 21, 1940, Lüth received the Type IX A boat U 43. From November 1940 to February 1942 he sank nine ships totaling 54,795 GRT in the North Atlantic, on six war patrols in 192 days at sea. On January 1, 1941, Lüth was promoted to Kapitänleutnant. On February 4, 1941, U 43, under his command, sank at the pier of the German U-boat base in Lorient due to negligence: a valve in the torpedo room, or the torpedo hatch, had not been properly closed. The boat was raised immediately, but was not ready for service again until a quarter of a year later. The incident evidently had no consequences for Lüth's further military career. In addition to the award of the Italian War Cross with Swords on November 1, 1941, he was mentioned in the Wehrmacht communiqué on January 14, 1942.

In May 1942 Lüth commissioned U 181, one of the Monsun boats of Type IX D 2. With this boat he undertook two war patrols totaling 333 days at sea. On his first patrol, from September 12, 1942, to January 18, 1943, Lüth sank twelve ships totaling 58,380 GRT in the South Atlantic. For this he received the Oak Leaves to the Knight's Cross of the Iron Cross on November 13, 1942.

His second war patrol with this boat, at 205 days at sea, was to become the second longest of the war. U 181 left the base at Bordeaux on March 23, 1943. In the following months it sank ten ships totaling 45,528 GRT in the Indian Ocean. He was promoted to Korvettenkapitän on April 1, 1943, and two weeks later, on April 15, 1943, was awarded the Swords to the Oak Leaves of the Knight's Cross (29th recipient). After the last sinking on August 11, 1943, Lüth became the first naval officer to be awarded the Diamonds to the Knight's Cross with Oak Leaves and Swords (7th recipient). On October 14, 1943, U 181 returned to Bordeaux. Under Lüth's command it had sunk a total of 22 ships totaling 103,908 GRT.
On January 15, 1944, Lüth was withdrawn from front-line service and assigned as chief of the 22nd U-boat Flotilla in Gotenhafen. In July he became head of the 1st Department at the Naval Academy (Marinekriegsschule) in Flensburg-Mürwik. On August 1, 1944, he was promoted to Fregattenkapitän. On September 1, 1944, the 31-year-old Lüth was promoted to Kapitän zur See and appointed commandant of the Marinekriegsschule.

Shortly before the end of the war, SS members of the Inspectorate of Concentration Camps who had reached the Flensburg area via the so-called Rat Line North were issued naval uniforms and false pay books in the Mürwik Special Zone. For this operation, Lüth, who was responsible for it, received the express backing of Dönitz. On May 5, 1945, Flensburg was occupied by British forces. Lüth, the city's combat commandant, had decreed immediately before the arrival of the Allies: “All soldiers and the civilian population are to be informed at once that it is incompatible with the upright bearing of a German and the pride of a National Socialist to greet the advancing enemy by waving cloths or similar actions.” When the British had prohibited the German units from giving the Hitler salute, Lüth defied this on May 8, 1945, with an order to the troops: “The German salute is and remains the salute of the Wehrmacht.”

The guard battalion, 400 men strong and commanded by Korvettenkapitän Peter E. Cremer (U 333 and U 2519), was not disarmed by the British for reasons of self-protection. Lüth had ordered that the men of the guard battalion were to shoot immediately at anyone who did not give the password when challenged. On May 14, 1945, shortly after midnight, when he failed to respond to the challenge of a patrol, Lüth was accidentally shot by the sentry on duty, Seaman Matthias Gottlob.
Lüth lay in state in the auditorium of the Naval School Mürwik and was buried two days later, on May 16, 1945, in the Adelby cemetery near Flensburg.
528611

U-Boat War Badge with Diamonds from the Estate of Kapitän zur See Wolfgang Lüth

The U-boat War Badge (1939) with Diamonds is among the rarest and most mythologised decorations of the Kriegsmarine. The piece discussed here is not an officially awarded badge but a privately made duplicate from the possession of Kapitän zur See Wolfgang Lüth, one of the most highly decorated German naval officers. It brings together the history of a standard badge, of a special grade that was never officially instituted, and of the biography of one of its best-known wearers.

The basic badge. The U-boat War Badge was instituted on 13 October 1939, in the first weeks of the war, by the Commander-in-Chief of the Kriegsmarine, Grossadmiral Erich Raeder. It was modelled on the U-boat War Badge of 1918 and was awarded in the name of the Commander of U-boats, Karl Dönitz. The Berlin firm of C. Schwerin & Sohn began production on 1 November 1939, and the first badges were delivered to the Presidial Chancellery of the Order Chancellery as early as 10 November 1939. The Viennese firm Souval later produced the badge as well. The standard piece was made first of gilt non-ferrous metal (bronze or tombac) and later of zinc; a cloth embroidered version also exists.

The design is unmistakable: a horizontally oval laurel wreath tied at the bottom, surmounted by an eagle with spread wings gripping a swastika set on its point. Below lies a stylised U-boat whose conning tower touches the tip of the swastika and whose ends overlap the wreath. The standard badge measures roughly 48 x 39 mm.

Award criteria. The badge could be awarded to all officers, non-commissioned officers and enlisted men of U-boats operating against the enemy who had proved themselves on two or more patrols. In the case of wounding, this requirement could be waived; the B.d.U. decided individual cases. Worthiness, good conduct and the absence of a detention sentence within the previous six months were also required. It was worn on the left breast, on and off duty. A total of 9,536 awards of the standard badge is recorded.

The diamond version. The badge with diamonds was a special badge that was never officially instituted. It grew out of naval practice: after the award of the Oak Leaves to the Knight's Cross of the Iron Cross, the corresponding combat badge was presented in this enhanced form, and only in special cases. Its hallmark is the swastika set with nine small stones. Recipients included Otto Kretschmer, Günther Prien, Joachim Schepke, Reinhard Hardegen, Erich Topp, Albrecht Brandi and Wolfgang Lüth. For Karl Dönitz himself, a special piece in gold was made; it carried an additional twelve diamonds evenly spaced around the laurel wreath and was somewhat larger. It was taken from him after his arrest on 23 May 1945; when it was returned, the diamond-set swastika was missing, and its whereabouts are unknown.

From 1944 the U-boat Front Clasp was added as a further grade of the award. Lüth also received it, on 12 October 1944.

Wolfgang Lüth. Wolfgang Lüth was born in Riga on 15 October 1913. He received the U-boat War Badge of 1939 on 18 February 1940. After the Oak Leaves to the Knight's Cross of 13 November 1942, he was granted the diamond badge on 26 January 1943, according to the sources. The Swords followed on 15 April 1943, and later that year he became the first naval officer to receive the Diamonds to the Knight's Cross, the seventh recipient of that grade. He ended the war as commandant of the Naval Academy at Mürwik. In the night leading into 14 May 1945 he was shot by a sentry in Flensburg. The funeral took place on 16 May 1945, and Dönitz delivered the eulogy.

The duplicate in question. The piece is described as a private commission for Lüth, made around 1943. It follows the classic Schwerin pattern and bears the maker's mark “Schwerin Berlin 68” on the reverse; the same stamp is known from ordinary Schwerin badges. It is made of fire-gilt non-ferrous metal. The swastika is applied as a separate plate and set with nine simulated stones, the rim mouldings are finely beaded and polished, and the reverse carries a bulbous pin with a round catch. Its dimensions of 48.24 x 38.77 mm lie very close to those given for the standard badge, and its weight is 25.49 g. The difference in material is notable: instead of genuine diamonds it carries imitation stones, which is consistent with a private second example.

The attribution rests on a confirmation from his widow, Ilse Lüth, written in 1977 to a collector of the time. According to it, her husband received a U-boat War Badge with diamonds from Dönitz in 1943 and had a duplicate made in order to protect the original from loss or damage in service. He is said to have worn this second piece from then on. As a collector's item, the badge is thus a vivid witness to how a special badge that was never formally regulated was worn and handled in practice.